watch
Branded psychology editorial cover showing "the dark side of success: what research shows about the psychological costs of achievement".

The Dark Side Of Success: What Research Shows About The Psychological Costs Of Achievement

Explore how achievement, power and status can affect perspectives, relationships and wellbeing, with evidence-informed ways to maintain sustainable ambition.

QUICK ANSWER
Achievement can provide opportunities, satisfaction and security while also introducing pressure, demands on time and concerns about status. Research on power and leadership suggests some context-dependent psychological risks, not an inevitable decline in empathy or wellbeing. Sustainable achievement includes attention to relationships, health and accountability.

Achieving a long-awaited goal may bring recognition, new responsibilities and greater financial security. It can also change expectations, reduce available time or make future setbacks feel more consequential. These consequences depend partly on the type of achievement and the environment in which it occurs. Understanding potential psychological costs can help people preserve what they value while pursuing ambitious goals, without assuming that success itself is harmful.

Power, Status, And Empathy

Power concerns the capacity to influence outcomes or control resources, whereas status concerns social standing. Achievement may increase one or both, but they are distinct. Someone can acquire professional responsibility without gaining substantial wealth, or receive public recognition without having authority over others.

Power can influence which information reaches a person and how much they depend on others’ feedback. The study described above suggests that some power-related conditions may affect perspective-taking. However, research tasks do not establish how every real-world leader will behave over time.

An accountable working arrangement can provide opportunities to hear competing viewpoints and evaluate decisions. Invite relevant feedback and make it possible for colleagues to raise concerns without retaliation. This addresses specific risks rather than presuming that authority inevitably corrupts. See fear of success.

RESEARCH NOTE
In a 2006 series of experiments and a correlational study, Galinsky and colleagues investigated power and perspective-taking. Some participants in higher-power conditions were less likely to take another person’s perspective in the tasks studied. These findings do not establish that every successful person becomes less empathetic.

Narcissism And Success

Narcissistic traits are studied as dimensions of personality, and their presence does not necessarily establish narcissistic personality disorder. It is inappropriate to diagnose someone based only on ambition, confidence or professional success.

A meta-analysis by Grijalva and colleagues found that narcissism was positively related to leadership emergence but not linearly related to leadership effectiveness. Self-rated effectiveness showed a different pattern from observer ratings. The findings distinguish being perceived as a leader from performing effectively in that role.

These results do not establish that achievement causes narcissism. Selective feedback, organizational incentives and existing traits may interact. Consider evaluating conduct and performance using observable evidence rather than assuming someone’s status reveals their personality. Explore identity-based goals.

Success And Relationship Costs

Achievement can alter available time and energy. A person taking on additional professional responsibilities may have less flexibility for shared activities, rest or caregiving. The change is not necessarily harmful, but its consequences deserve attention.

Discuss important commitments with the people affected. A temporary period of demanding work may be manageable when responsibilities and expectations are clear. A persistent mismatch between available time and obligations may require a more substantial change rather than better time management alone.

Recognition can also bring pressure to maintain a particular public image. Someone may fear that a setback will undermine their sense of identity or relationships. Evaluate whether expectations still serve a meaningful purpose. Read the happiness paradox and why money does not buy happiness.

Maintaining Psychological Health Through Success

Develop measures of progress beyond status and output. These might include the quality of decisions, opportunities to learn, the condition of important relationships and the ability to meet health needs. The relevant measures depend on the person’s priorities and circumstances.

A useful practice is to review the demands associated with a new achievement. Identify which responsibilities are essential, which can be shared and which require clear limits. Feedback from trusted people may help reveal consequences that are difficult to recognize independently.

Protect adequate rest and appropriate healthcare. If persistent anxiety, exhaustion, loss of interest or other significant symptoms arise, seek professional assessment rather than interpreting them as the unavoidable price of success.

Achievement and wellbeing can support each other when goals and circumstances are compatible. The purpose of considering psychological risks is to make ambition more informed and sustainable, not to discourage achievement.

KEY TAKEAWAY
Achievement may change responsibilities, social dynamics and personal expectations. Maintain realistic boundaries and accountability, while recognizing that psychological costs are neither universal nor unavoidable.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does Success Change People Psychologically?

It can change experiences and circumstances, but outcomes vary.

What Is A Potential Risk Of Power?

Some research suggests power may affect perspective-taking in certain contexts.

Does Success Cause Narcissism?

No, evidence does not establish that achievement inevitably causes narcissism.

Can Achievement Affect Relationships?

Yes, changing demands and responsibilities may influence relationships.

How Can Ambition Remain Sustainable?

Review priorities, protect health and relationships, and maintain meaningful feedback and accountability.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to Top

Discover more from Thoughts and Reality

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading